Gear guide · research-backed picks
Best Toasters and Toaster Ovens
Toast is a two-minute job that bad appliances turn into a five-minute frustration. The honest tiers: the two-slicer with real browning control, the countertop oven that replaces your main oven for small jobs, and the $30 budget pick that still toasts evenly — plus what to skip.
Every kitchen needs fast browning: toast for breakfast, reheated msemen, a tray of cookies you don't want to fire the big oven for. Two appliances do that job — the pop-up toaster and the countertop toaster oven — and they overlap less than people assume. A toaster is pure speed for slices; a toaster oven adds broiling, small bakes, and reheating that keeps crust crisp instead of steaming it soft in a microwave.
The market splits into basic two-slicers, long-slot four-slicers, and toaster ovens from simple to convection-equipped. What actually changes the food is even browning and consistent timing, not digital displays. Our chocolate-chip-cookies reheat beautifully in a toaster oven and turn rubbery in a microwave — that versatility is the real reason the category exists.
This guide covers the specs that matter, the honest pick at each tier, and the traps worth skipping.
How we chose: picks are selected on material, build quality, maker reputation, and long-term owner feedback — not sponsorships. Our own kitchen hasn't run long-term trials on every model, and we say so rather than pretend otherwise. Links point to search results so you always see current listings. Affiliate disclosure: if you buy through a link, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — see ourfull disclosure.
What actually matters
Even browning is everything. Cheap toasters heat unevenly because their elements are sparsely placed, so one face of the bread darkens while the other stays pale — the most common owner complaint in the category. Second is slot width: bagels, English muffins, and thick-cut bakery bread need wide or long slots, and squeezing them into narrow slots produces toast that's scorched outside and raw inside. For toaster ovens, check the interior height — a 6-slice unit fits a standard muffin tin or a small casserole; a 4-slice unit barely fits a personal pizza. Finally, a genuine 'keep warm' or reheat mode earns its place; a timer that goes to eleven does not.
Traps to avoid
Skip glass-sided toasters that advertise 'see-through' browning — the glass fogs and the view never helps. Avoid oversized digital toaster ovens for small counters: a 6-slice convection model earns its footprint, a 9-slice one hogs it and heats the kitchen. And be skeptical of sub-$20 no-name toasters: their browning dials are often cosmetic, running full heat regardless of setting.
Our recommendations
Best overall toaster: Breville the 'A Bit More' 2-Slice (BTA720XL)
The signature button adds 30 seconds to a cycle already running — the fix for every 'it's almost there' moment, and the reason owners stay loyal. Wide slots, an even element layout that actually browns both faces, and lift-look functionality around $100. Simple, durable, and honest about what a toaster should be.
Amazon: UK - US - IT - AU - DE - FR - ES - UAE
Best splurge (toaster oven): Cuisinart Chef's Convection Toaster Oven (TOB-260N1)
Around $250, it genuinely replaces a wall oven for small jobs: real convection for even cookies and roasting, 15 cooking functions, dual-cook timing, and an interior that holds a 13-inch pizza or a whole chicken. Overkill for toast alone — but if it displaces oven use in summer, it pays for itself in comfort and energy.
Amazon: UK - US - IT - AU - DE - FR - ES - UAE
Best budget: Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Toaster Oven (31413)
Around $40–50 and it covers the fundamentals: even toast, a usable 30-minute timer, a bake tray, and a compact footprint. Browning is not as precise as the premium units and the exterior runs warm, but for toast, fries, and reheating slices it does the honest job — the best value in the category.
Amazon: UK - US - IT - AU - DE - FR - ES - UAE
Common questions
Do I need a toaster and a toaster oven, or just one?
Just one for most households. If you eat sliced toast daily and rarely bake small, a two-slicer is faster and cheaper to run. If you reheat leftovers, broil open sandwiches, or bake for one or two, the toaster oven wins — it does everything the toaster does, just slightly slower per slice.
Is convection worth it in a toaster oven?
Yes for baked goods and roasting — the fan evens out hot spots and crisps surfaces, which is why reheated banana-bread slices taste oven-fresh. For simple toast it makes no difference, so don't pay for convection if toast is your only use.